Massive disclaimer: It is ridiculous to compare music this way! and lists are either sterile countdowns full of criticspeak, or as obscure as possible (this is tempting, believe me!) and padded out with a load of stuff you don't really listen to a lot but think will make you sound a bit more interesting than just admitting ah yeah actually The Strokes album was pretty good. HOWEVER, I spent 2000-2004 pretty much just listening to Bright Eyes and The Smiths, so there's no reason not to be honest about this. I don't understand or trust music reviews if they are factual/clinical, so i'll try and make this more personal.Firstly, records that missed the cut or I couldn't be bothered to fit into the list (and i'm not man enough to let the others down), or I thought about at last minute or I loved at the time but very slightly not as much now...The Decemberists - "picaresque", The Microphones - "the glow pt 2", Fiery Furnaces - "gallowsbird's bark", Bright Eyes - "i'm wide awake it's morning", The Shins - "oh inverted world", BARR - "beyond reinforced jewel case", The Strokes - "is this it?", Rusty Santos - "the heavens", Deerhunter - "cryptograms", Kait0 - "band red", The Libertines - "up the bracket", Super Furry Animals - "rings around the world", Camera Obscura - "biggest bluest hi fi", Arcade Fire - "funeral", Polyphonic Spree - "the beginning stages of...", Dirty Projectors - "bitte orca", Yeah Yeah Yeahs - "fever to tell", Safetyword - "man's name is legion", The Books - "lost and safe", Bearsuit - "team ping pong", Lightning Bolt - "wonderful rainbow", Parenthetical Girls - "entanglements", Sweet Baboo - "hello wave", Nico Muhly - "mothertongue", The Bronx - "ii", Fuck Buttons - "Street Horrrsing", Amy Winehouse - "back to black", The xx - "xx"
A fair few of those I like equally as much as any of the following (which shows you the way things will go here). Any of these could be in any order (roughly)! Don't be fooled by the numbers or pretence that we are building up to something important (i'm kidding, we are):50. Devendra Banhart - "rejoicing in the hands..."49. Various - "antifolk vol. 1" (2002) [only compilation allowed]48. Gillian Welch - "time (the revelator)" (2002)47. Lift To Experience - "the texas jerusalem crossroads" (2001)46. Black Dice - "creature comforts" (2004)45. Flying Lotus - "los angeles" (2008)44. The Dirtbombs - "ultraglide in black" (2001)43. Deerhoof - "milkman" (2004)42. Erase Eratta - "other animals" (2001)41. M.Ward - "the transfiguration of vincent" (2003)40. Missy Elliot - "respect m.e." (2006) [FINAL compilation allowed! too much filler on her albums, listen to this more than any other comp.]39. Stars of the Lid - "...and their refinement of the decline" (2007)38. Ryan Adams - "gold" (2001)37. Panda Bear - "person pitch" (2007)36. Tindersticks - "can our love…" (2001)35. OOIOO - "gold and green" (2000)34. Electrelane - "the power out" (2004)33. Kate Rusby - "the girl who couldn't fly" (2006)32. Wild Beasts - "limbo, panto" / "two dancers" (2008/2009) [CHEATING. i can't seperate]31. Adam Green - "friends of mine" (2003)30. Joanna Newsom - "the milk eyed mender" (2004)29. The Knife - "silent shout" (2006)28. Emeralds - "solar bridge" (2008)27. Mono - "walking cloud and deep red sky, flag fluttered and sun shined" (2004)26. Grandaddy - "the sophtware slump" (2000)
25. The White Stripes - "white blood cells" (2001)
I remember hearing them showcase these new songs on one (of their many) Peel sessions, as well as a Marlena Dietrich cover and Hello Operator (not off this album) and it gave me shivers, good ones. Love everything about this album, and it holds up better than their others. Got the praise it deserved, and now, as if it couldn't get any better for them, they get to number 25! IN THIS LIST.
24. The Detroit Cobras - "life, love and leaving" (2001)
I owe it to the 2001 version of me to put this way up in my list. Amazing sleazy garage covers record of old soul songs and standards. I don't think i've listened to this for a good few years. Doing so now. Still love it. Got into this when I was deep into Everett True / Careless Talk mag, back when it was like a mass produced fanzine.
23. Broadcast - "haha sound" (2003)
This is the Broadcast album that i've listened to and come back to the most, their 60s up-beat pop record but still dark and Germanic. The least '2000s' sounding record in this list?! I think this is the one they recorded themselves in their basement. It sounds breezy and light (for them).
22. GAS - "pop" (2000)
Gas - Oktember A1
This is slightly cheating as my actual vote is the whole of the Nah Und Fer box set (2008) but most of that is from the '90s bar this one record (best disc - Oktember). More washy ambience and crackles and drip drops and underwater techno, slightly Krauty and strange and URGH! rewarding, sorry, I was supposed to keep this personal... urrrm, nice with a book.
21. Brian McBride - "when the detail lost it's freedom" (2005)
No not that Brian McBride. This is one half of Stars of the Lid, but I much prefer this to SotL, it's sleepy (had no idea I was so sleepy) and sad (knew about that), occasional vocals but mostly instrumental. Piano/guitar/brass/not much of a pulse, actually - I have no idea what instruments are making most of these noises but AHHHHH IT'S BEAUTIFUL. this review here explains it a lot better (and worse) than I ever could. I should have placed this higher but it's too late now.
NEXT UP 20 - 11. NOT because I want to drag this out!!! but because I haven't written it yet, and I don't want this one to be too long...